Busted: 2005
Where: California
Offense: Drunk Driving

It broke our then teenage hearts when Nick Carter of the Backstreet Boys got arrested in 2005 for drunk driving. His squeaky clean image was gone faster than a cupcake at Anna Nicole Smith's house... We had to use an appropriate 2005 reference.

He was first pulled over for a traffic violation, but the officer deemed him intoxicated, and when Nick failed the sobriety test. The rest is history.

His mugshot may look pretty good, but we're still embarrassed by the fact that we listed him as our "Celebrity Crush" in our 8th grade yearbook.