Holy cuteness! Jay McGuiness of the Wanted and One Direction's Liam Payne have grown up into teen heartthrobs and for good reason. Look at how darn cute they were in their old yearbook photos!

McGuiness, who grew up in the Newark, England (not New Jersey, guys!), is a dashing young lad with those freckles! And that D.A.R.E. shirt? It might explain why he's such party animal along with his band mates in the Wanted.

Payne, who grew up in Wolverhampton, England, is cute as a button in his school uniform with his pinchable cheeks and spiky hair. Who knew he would grow into such an international superstar?

So who has the cutest yearbook photo? Vote for Jay or Liam below.