When will the Jonas Brothers learn not to play the Plead the Fifth game on Bravo's 'Watch What Happens Live'?

Big brother Kevin Jonas made headlines in April when he appeared to throw shade at Selena Gomez while answering the game's notoriously awkward questions, and now Joe Jonas is afraid he'll find himself in "big trouble" for his responses on Tuesday night's (July 23) show.

For his first question, host Andy Cohen asked Joe to rank former Disney starlets Miley Cyrus, Demi Lovato, and Selena Gomez, in order of favorite to least favorite,.

Joe knew he could only refuse one question of three -- and probably feared what cringe-worthy question would be next -- so he did finally 'fess up, diplomatically chosing ex Demi as his fave before struggling with the rest of his answer:

"Me and her are very cool now, so favorite: Demi. Oh wow, I wanna say -- I can't say Plead the Fifth yet, this is bad," Joe says. He took a moment before continuing, obviously pained. "I'll go Miley and Selena, because Selena, I haven't seen you in a while. I saw Miley, she was very nice to me recently."

Wow, did Selena just get dissed by a Jonas again?!

Enjoy Joe's extreme discomfort -- and see what question finally made him Plead the Fifth -- in the video above!