No. 1: Justin Bieber With Steve Buscemi Eyes

This wins for freakiest Justin Bieber meme by a long shot. Steve Buscemi's eyes are only OK, well, when they're on Steve Buscemi. When the 'Boardwalk Empire' star's semi-bulging peepers are cropped onto another person's face, the results are terrifying and haunting.

There are actually two separate sites dedicated to the Photoshop wonders of Steve Buscemi eyes, including the tumblr page Chicks With Steve Buscemi Eyes as well as the celebrities with Steve Buscemi eyes section on sadanduseless.com, where this nightmarish, scary a-- Bieber picture lives.