As if Selena Gomez and Lucy Hale could look any more similar, both ladies recently stepped out in the same red-hot scarlet Dior dress. Who wore it best?

Selena Gomez donned the short and sexy number at the 'Rudderless' premiere, pairing the cleavage-baring frock with white bangles, nude nails and a tight updo worthy of a ballerina. The dress looked fun and flirty on the actress-singer, who no doubt sizzled all night long.

Of course, Lucy Hale gets props for rocking the Dior dress first, wearing the ensemble at the 2014 Teen Choice Awards. We love how she managed to fuse two different looks into the number -- a sweet, feminine flair with her loose waves, but also a harder edge with midnight black nails. Hot!

Who wore it best? Selenators and Halers, cast your vote for Selena Gomez or Lucy Hale in the poll below!

See Selena Gomez + More Celebs' Yearbook Photos