Haley Reinhart

The five remaining 'American Idol' contestants were challenged to take on songs from "Now and Then" tonight, and for her "Now" songs, Jimmy Iovine suggested that Haley Reinhart perform the unreleased Lady Gaga track 'You and I' off of her upcoming album, 'Born This Way.' Reinhart received Gaga's blessing and decided to give the song a go tonight.

There's no denying that Haley Reinhart, one of two remaining females on 'American Idol' this season, has a beautiful voice; so it was fitting for the blond sweetheart to tackle Carole King's 'Beautiful' on tonight's episode. But Reinhart was beyond beautiful. She was, in fact, godlike, according to judge Steven Tyler.

Casey Abrams and Haley Reinhart are both in possession of raspy, smoky, husky and ultimately sexy voices -- so this duet of Carole King's 'I Feel the Earth Move' was no yin vs. yang. Their duet of one King's biggest hits was all sizzle and heat.

'American Idol' contestant and Chicago native Haley Reinhart spoke with her hometown's Showbiz Shelly on Z96 radio recently about her experiences so far on the show. She enthused about new judges Steven Tyler and Jennifer Lopez, but lamented the difficulty she's had watching fellow singers getting voted off the show.

In tonight's episode, the remaining 'American Idol' contestants were allowed to play instruments, use backup singers or go a capella to showcase their other talents and gifts.