9 'American Idol' Contestants Who Should Have Won9 'American Idol' Contestants Who Should Have WonFrom Melinda Doolittle to Pia Toscano, these eliminated finalists deserved MUCH better.Matthew Scott DonnellyMatthew Scott Donnelly
Kelly Clarkson Caps Off Breakneck 'Idol' Finale Medley With Huge 'Moment'Kelly Clarkson Caps Off Breakneck 'Idol' Finale Medley With Huge 'Moment'Unfortunately, the voting public got the winner wrong...for the eighth time in 10 years.Matthew Scott DonnellyMatthew Scott Donnelly