Vino Alan showed his soulful side on ‘X Factor’ tonight (Nov. 14) with his version of Al Green’s ‘Let’s Stay Together.’ But does he have what it takes to win America’s vote?

The judges had mixed feelings about his performance. “Your voice is so soulful…it doesn’t make sense that that voice comes out of your body, but it works,” praised Britney Spears.

However, some of the other judges weren't quite so impressed with his delivery of the song. Demi Lovato offered the following words of criticism: “I like this performance better than last week’s, but at the same time, I have to say I was a little bored.” Simon Cowell agreed with her assessment. “I was happy to see you so high up in the rankings last week, because I think you needed confidence … but that song wasn’t as good as last week.”

However, L.A. Reid stood behind the tattooed singer all the way. “You put your soul into that, you sang it so strong,” he began. “You have a classic voice, one of the best voices I’ve ever heard on this stage, and this song was a great platform for it. I’m really proud of you, my man.”

Now, it's up to viewers to decide whether or not Alan deserves to win this thing! What do you think?