The American Idol judges are expanding their expertise beyond music and to Peeps-flavored milk!

During their March 10 visit to Jimmy Kimmel Live!, Jennifer Lopez, Keith Urban and Harry Connick Jr. tried the new spring-themed beverage.

"I already know what I think!" Jennifer joked when Jimmy whipped out a tray of Peeps-flavored milk. And in case you're wondering, the flavors are Easter Eggnog, Chocolate Marshmallow and regular Marshmallow. Yum?

Sadly, Simon Cowell wasn't present to contribute his famous tell-it-like-it-is opinion, but luckily, the three judges had things covered.

"That's amazing!" Harry raved of the Chocolate Marshmallow milk.

"It is kind of good," Jimmy agreed as he sipped his mixture of all three flavors.

"It's so milky sugar," Jennifer agreed, taking another sip of her original Marshmallow-flavored drink.

The best part? "It's the bottom of the cereal bowl without having to eat cereal!" Jimmy announced.

This is the first we're hearing of Peeps-flavored milk, but we have a feeling it won't be the last. The Prairie Farms press release announcing the new beverage said that "creating a line of flavors that joins the two strong brands was an obvious choice." And, in case you're wondering, St. Louis' KSDK reports that Peeps milk has 37 grams of sugar per serving. (For comparison, a 12-ounce Coca-Cola has 39 grams of sugar.)

We're not sure if we'll be trying the Peeps-inspired beverage, but we're glad that it got six thumbs up from Harry, Keith and Jennifer. You can watch the American Idol judges try the milk in the video above!

See Jennifer Lopez + More Stars' Wardrobe Malfunctions