Ed Sheeran and Madison Beer have both recently covered Sam Smith's emotional summer smash 'Stay With Me.' Their versions (and voices!) are completely different, but we have to ask: Whose cover do you like best?

OK, so if someone other than Sam Smith were to perform the swoon-worthy song, you know it'd be Ed Sheeran. The moving lyrics and hard-hitting vocals were practically made for the redheaded Brit's voice, which was only enhanced by the choir who backed him up. Our hearts are still fluttering over this one.

Madison Beer's version of the ballad is equally as amazing -- though very different! -- than Ed Sheeran's cover. First of all, let's just take a second to be blown away by the fact that she is only 15 years old, and has one seriously powerful voice. In fact, it is Madison's strong vocals that are the driving force in her cover of 'Stay With Me' -- and we love it.

Which pop star covers Sam Smith's 'Stay With Me' best? Cast your vote for Ed Sheeran or Madison Beer in the poll below!

Watch Ed Sheeran Cover 'Stay With Me'

Watch Madison Beer Cover 'Stay With Me'

See Ed Sheeran + More Celebs Who Look Like '90s Nicktoon Characters